DEPARTMENT OF OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY, YONSEI UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MEDICINE, SEOUL, REPUBLIC OF KOREA©ö. SEVERANCE BIOMEDICAL SCIENCE INSTITUTE, YONSEI UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MEDICINE, SEOUL, REPUBLIC OF KOREA©÷. THE AIRWAY MUCUS INSTITUTE, YONSEI UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MEDICINE, SEVERANCE HOSPITAL, SEOUL, REPUBLIC OF KOREA©ø |
¸ñÀû: Olfactory neuroblastoma (ONB) is a rare cancer originating from the
neural crest of the olfactory epithelium. The current standard
treatment involves surgical resection with or without radiotherapy. In
contrast to other sinonasal tumors, ONB, despite achieving complete
response with initial treatment, exhibits a high recurrence rate,
particularly with a significant proportion of local and regional
failures. In this study, we aim to analyze the failure patterns
following initial treatment and investigate potential strategies for
enhancing treatment outcomes. ¹æ¹ý:From 1990 to 2023, we retrospectively analyzed patients diagnosed with
ONB and treated at Severance Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Patients without adequate medical records, those for whom primary
treatment was incomplete, or those lost to follow-up before evaluating
treatment response were excluded. Overall survival (OS) and disease-
free survival (DFS) were assessed using the Kaplan–Meier method. Based
on treatment response after primary therapy, patients were categorized
into Complete Response (CR) and Progressive Disease groups. Among CR
patients, further classification was made into No Evidence of Disease
(NED), primary lesion recurrence, nodal recurrence, and distant
metastasis categories for analysis. Survival curves were compared
between groups using the log-rank test. °á°ú:A total of 44 patients were included in the analysis. When overall
survival was stratified by Kadish stage into Low grade (A, B) and High
grade (C, D), the 5-year survival rates were 93.0% and 70.9%,
respectively, while the 10-year survival rates were 81.7% and 56.7%,
respectively, and this difference was statistically significant
(p=0.011). Among patients who achieved Complete Remission (CR) and
those who experienced recurrence after initial treatment, the Kadish
stage was the only statistically significant factor linked to an
elevated risk of recurrence (p<0.05). Patient age, histological grade,
surgical approach (craniofacial resection, endoscopic surgery,
combined surgery), and type of adjuvant treatment were not associated
with recurrence. Among patients who initially achieved CR but
eventually experienced recurrence, the recurrence pattern was
classified as primary lesion recurrence, nodal recurrence, and distant
metastasis. Among the 6 patients with nodal recurrence, the time to
recurrence was longer (average 38.6 months), and the majority (83%)
were initially at Kadish stage C or higher. The sites of recurrence
were predominantly ipsilateral neck levels II and III, although
occurrences in ipsilateral level I and contralateral level I were also
noted.
In the analysis focused on Kadish stage C patients (N=20), nodal
recurrence was observed in 25% of the total, with a nodal recurrence
rate of 29.4% among those who received a CR judgment for initial
treatment. When analyzing patients who underwent surgery after initial
treatment at stage C, among the 16 patients who received postoperative
radiotherapy (including concurrent chemoradiotherapy), 4 included the
neck region in the radiotherapy field, and 12 did not. The probability
of nodal recurrence in these subgroups was 0% and 41.6%, respectively.
°á·Ð:In this retrospective cohort, patients with a high Kadish stage
exhibited significantly worse clinical outcomes, particularly
emphasizing the necessity to consider nodal recurrence with a long-
term duration in these cases. Even in patients without neck nodes at
the initial diagnosis, If the stage is C or higher, it may be
considered to include elective radiotherapy or neck field in
postoperative radiotherapy. |